84–78
.519 · RS 725 / RA 722 · Σ 61.9 WAR
CFMike Trout10.5
LFRickey Henderson9.9
RFLarry Walker9.8
SSRobin Yount10.5
2BEddie Collins9.8
3BGeorge Brett9.4
1BGeorge Sisler9.8
PEd Walsh12.8
CDarrell Porter7.6
DHDavid Ortiz6.4
SPPete Alexander12.7
RPJohn Hiller7.9
| Pos | Player | Peak | Era · Team | Peak line | WAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C | Darrell Porter | 1979 | Free Agency · Oakland Athletics | 142 OPS+ · .291/.421/.484 · 20 HR | 7.6 |
| 1B | George Sisler | 1920 | Liveball · St. Louis Cardinals | 181 OPS+ · .407/.449/.632 · 19 HR · 42 SB | 9.8 |
| 2B | Eddie Collins | 1910 | Deadball · Cleveland Naps | 150 OPS+ · .324/.382/.418 · 3 HR · 81 SB | 9.8 |
| 3B | George Brett | 1980 | Free Agency · Kansas City Royals | 203 OPS+ · .390/.454/.664 · 24 HR | 9.4 |
| SS | Robin Yount | 1982 | Free Agency · Milwaukee Brewers | 166 OPS+ · .331/.379/.578 · 29 HR | 10.5 |
| LF | Rickey Henderson | 1990 | Free Agency · Oakland Athletics | 189 OPS+ · .325/.439/.577 · 28 HR · 65 SB | 9.9 |
| CF | Mike Trout | 2012 | Modern · Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | 168 OPS+ · .326/.399/.564 · 30 HR · 49 SB | 10.5 |
| RF | Larry Walker | 1997 | Steroid · Colorado Rockies | 178 OPS+ · .366/.452/.720 · 49 HR · 33 SB | 9.8 |
| DH | David Ortiz | 2007 | Modern · Boston Red Sox | 171 OPS+ · .332/.445/.621 · 35 HR | 6.4 |
| SP | Ed Walsh | 1912 | Deadball · Chicago White Sox | 149 ERA+ · 27-17 · 2.15 ERA · 2.59 FIP | 12.8 |
| SP | Pete Alexander | 1920 | Liveball · Chicago Cubs | 166 ERA+ · 27-14 · 1.91 ERA · 2.51 FIP | 12.7 |
| RP | John Hiller | 1973 | Expansion · Detroit Tigers | 283 ERA+ · 10-5 · 1.44 ERA · 2.26 FIP | 7.9 |